Tuesday, April 21, 2009

South Africa’s Final Stretch to Democracy


Jacob Zuma is widely tipped to be the next president of South Africa

by Rejoice Ngwenya, Pretoria, South Africa.

South Africa holds its fourth post-apartheid election tomorrow. Being an important economy within Africa and to other regions of the world, one should have expected the same media frenzy that characterized previous elections to be more than ever present, not least because the next FIFA World soccer tournament will be held in South Africa.

Barack Obama’lightning world tours, Somalia’s pirate attacks, Zimbabwe’s Government of National Unity and a host of other attention-grabbing world events have taken the vigor out of the intrigues surrounding this vital election. Besides, characters like Jacob Zuma and his controversial hangers-on and Nelson Mandela have not stopped making news, so before we know it, the world would have been completely oblivious to the fact that for once in Southern Africa, elections can be after all, be free, fair and entertaining!

But there also seems to be citizen’s interest fatigue in politics. It has fallen to its lowest ebb, such that no one wants to care any more. My feeling is that just like in Botswana, Mozambique and Zimbabwe, citizens are more obsessed with political brand names than individual value addition. The late Zimbabwe vice-president and nationalist Simon Muzenda is alleged to have once told supporters at a rally that even if ZANU-PF (his ruling party) fielded a baboon, the primate would still win! So does it not matter that the wheels of justice have been deflated when the National Prosecuting Authority drops charges of corruption against Jacob Zuma? The answer in Pretoria is short and curt: who wants to know?

It would appear however, that only mischief makers gastronomically aligned to the ruling ANC have managed to, albeit negatively, sustained local interest.

One such character is Julius, the fiery leader of African National Congress Youth League (ANCYL) who ironically hails a stone throw from Zimbabwe’s Limpopo River and has proved that throwing political stones at political big wigs is another day’s work. And he has an opposite number, Mbazima Shilowa, the ‘genius’ behind the emergence of ANC’s most daring political competitor, Congress of the People (COPE)

And Julius has said all there is to say; killing for Zuma, two thirds majority for ANC, faked African dancing of one politician or another. He has also accused Inkatha Freedom Party’s (IFP) octogenarian leader Mangosuthu Buthelezi of hanging too long in the game. And soby now, the boyish protagonist is awaiting two outcomes – at least according to a waiter at a nearby Pretoria hotel – an outright win for ANC or his own ‘expulsion’ from ACNYL executive committee.

Reports, suggest that Andile Lungisa and woman youth activist Vuyiswa Tulelo are keen to replace the motor-mouth Julius who they say has spoiled the good image of ANCYL. As if good image counted in African politics. But views from the Tshwane streets are that it will take more than just charisma and high moral ground to ‘depose’ Julius.

Whatever the outcome of tomorrow’s elections, Julius is assured a job, thanks to the Black Economic Empowerment (BEE), a form of socialized quota to even the unbalanced labour market. Most analysts agree however that South Africa’s glaring income disparities have become more distinct even where the black government claims it is successful.

If anything, opposition contestants like Helen Zille of the Democratic Alliance(DA), COPE’s Mvume Dandala, Democratic Alliance’s Helen Zille, Inkatha Freedom Party’s(IFP) Mangosuthu Buthelezi, Independent Democrats’s Patricia de Lille and United Democratic Movement’s(UDM) Bantu Holomisa have at one time or other insisted that BEE is the password to wealth for a few ANC cronies like Tokyo Sexwale and Cyril Ramaphosa.

Worse still, when one is confronted with statistics that more than two-thirds of the South African population is considered poor, while those who live in shanty towns from Cape Town to Musina could as well even outnumber Zimbabwe’s entire population, BEE’s ‘success’ becomes just another term in the self-delusive game of pretense that politics solves everything. Certainly not in the case of the ordinary South African, who apart from being unemployed will have to grapple with poor public education and rising levels of violence and HIV Aids.

And so after South Africa’s electoral protagonists have so far spent nearly R400 million [USD40 million] on the campaign trail, will it be ANC’s Jacob Zuma, COPE’s Mvume Dandala, DA’s Helen Zille, IFP’s Mangosuthu Buthelezi, ID’s Patricia de Lille, UDM’s Bantu Holomisa ruling the political roost after Wednesday? Only ballot papers will tell.

Rejoice Ngwenya is director of Coalition for Liberal Market Solutions in Harare and an affiliate of www.AfricanLiberty.org

12 comments:

  1. If only Jacob Zuma was not standing for elections, i'd have had some hope for South Africa. When are we going to elect real leaders in the caliber of Obama in Africa instead of always producing stooges of the political machine. I can mention so many countries in Africa where leaders like zuma were elected and we all know the outcome.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Rejoice, many thanks for this incisive analysis. I am really very concerned about recent developments in South Africa.

    The meteoric comeback of Jacob Zuma, a man fired by Thabo Mbeki as Vice president on rape and corruption charges (and acquitted only after he admitted he had had unprotected sex with a woman whom he knew was HIV positive) is very worrisome.

    I mean, honestly, do people want such a man to president of a country as important to the region as South Africa?

    If he can't exercise, discipline, and self restraint in such "small" matters, what kind of judgment calls is he gonna make when the stakes are worth millions of South African lives. Being president is a tough job that requires a considerable amount of discretion and judgment calls...and with Jacob Zuma at the helm, I'm really very worried. Let's be careful.

    ReplyDelete
  3. can we ask ourselves why people actually want Zuma in the first place?
    He may have been involved in bad press but what's the other side of the story.

    Great article, Etse!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great article Rejoice...i think you nailed it when you characterized the situation in SA as “political fatigue.” I may be wrong on this but i think we experienced a similar situation in Ghana.

    People didn’t like the NPP but this objection was less problematic compared to their uncertainty over the NDC.

    I've seen many South Africans say the same thing: "I like the ANC/SA but do I really want JZ as my president."

    So DK you're right on point, you always have this intelligent way of saying exactly what's on mind: "do people want such a man to be president of a country as important to the region as South Africa?" Excellent question!

    MIghTy African, the only reason why people ‘like’ Zuma is either because they don't care about the future of SA, are blinded by what is known as "petty politics", their hatred for Mbeki, the fact that there is no other viable option and some sheer nostalgic feelings for his apartheid era heroics. Take that away and Zuma is just a political liability.

    Ps: By the way MIghTy African let me put on record that this article was written by Rejoice Ngwenya, not me...thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Alexander conquered the whole world except — Alexander. Emperor of the earth, he
    was the servile slave of his own passions. William George Jordan(Author of the Kingship of Self Control). More examples abound... I think is is easier to conquer and control the world than to conquer and control self...

    For a nation being raped, pillaged and ravaged by HIV/AIDS I think what I find totally irresponsible and very very very mind boggling is that Jacob Zuma had unprotected sex with a woman whom he knew was HIV positive... I would call a psychiatrist to check him up... South Africa needs a leader whose actions tell a different story - the young tend to believe and follow more what they see than what they hear... by this very fact, if I had a say, I would without giving it a second thought, bar him from running for public office because his actions endanger a whole generation of young people... good points DK and Etse... my five cents...

    afeseh.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I could not believe what i heard on BBC news today at 6pm.There was the news areticle about the SA election and the tone went something like this(i am paraphrasing)..."can the election results lift black people out of poverty? My heart sunk!this is our glorious rainbow country.There was no need for any discriminating slur in the news.Do we only have BLACK SOUTH AFRICANS? when will we fail to see beyound the hue of our skins?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi Mr Baley Wene Yayra,
    I'm surprised such a news feature was aired on BBC but isn't it true that a large population of black South Africans are poor? But if the report was meant to racist, then you have a point...thanks for sharing!

    ReplyDelete
  8. ..the white Afrikaners and other white minorities in South Africa, not to mention the Indian, Greek, Jewish and mixed races are all rightful citizens of South Africa and are as vested in this as the blacks.

    I don't see the point the BBC is trying to make here. The western media is fond of polarized reporting. I think the BBC should be ashamed of such reportage. Thanks for bringing this to attention, Baley.

    ReplyDelete
  9. It is rather sickening to see people scan media and pass judgement without the total facts, because the media ignores total facts. All court documents on Zuma court procedings are available on http://www.friendsofjz.co.za/documents.asp if you realy need the truth, you would read.

    As for people saying we don't care about the future of this country is just the nature of people looking from outside. The media has not told the truth about Mbeki's presidency, his hiring of Capitalist George Bizos, his GEAR passion, his workings with NGcuka and the CIA, his workings with Leornard McCathy and CIA. And I assume he has something with Mark Thatcher planned Equitorial Guinea coup and the 2million bail. NO ONE EVER TELLS THE TRUTH ABOUT MBEKI AND HIS 'hanger-on' as Rejoice calls people who support Zuma.

    Now we all know that the reason people created such huge anti-Zuma sentiment was because they dont want a man lesse educated than them running the country, why din't they say that when he put his life on the line for the ANC during apartheid years?

    South Africa has seen a lot of prejudiced press but Jacob Zuma has seen worse! he has been the most media hated human being in South Africa, why!
    1. They see him they see the COMMUNISTS that support him!
    2. They see him they see 'a' ZULU, that frowned upon uneducated statistic of South Africa, sometimes labeled violent,
    3. They see him they see a lesser being, uneducated, polygamous,
    and with the amount of media persecution he has received, everyone believes the hype.

    It is rather said that people like Rejoice have not corrected the misquoting, all intentionaly, of Jacob Zuma's court statements but feel justified to make judgements(personal) and pass them as journalistic analysis.
    the worse deveil in this whole saga has been the Media, NPA, Thabo Mbeki, Deputy Pres. Phumzile Mlambo Ngcuka as the phone transcripts will show, they damaged South Africa to service their own agendas, it it is said that most people think we are stupid to frown upon that.

    ReplyDelete
  10. ..Sabstance, many thanks for these insightful comments. Obviously, you are an ardent supporter of Jacob Zuma. I think Zuma is very popular with the majority as well as the Communists party and he represents the choice of the South African people (whether for good or for bad remains to be seen).

    I also have a lot of respect for the South Africa Communists' Party (most notably Joe Slovo) for their courageous role in fighting the racist white minority apartheid regime.

    After all, when Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher supported the apartheid regime under their so-called "constructive engagement policy" in the 1980s, it was the communists in Cuba, SACP and Russia that came to aid South Africa. Believe me, I despise Reagan and Thatcher as much as you do. I think they are as racists as the apartheid regime for such hypocrisy.

    For me, the thing about Zuma that I cannot reconcile is the gross irresponsibility he showed by sleeping unprotected with an HIV infected woman. That was very sloppy judgment and recklessly irresponsible for a man who will be president of a nation as important as South Africa.

    Obviously, he wouldn't be my choice because of this, but if the South African people want him, (as they have overwhelmingly demonstrated) then so be it. May God be with Africa.

    ReplyDelete
  11. ..I also wanna use this avenue to praise the late Chris Hani, also of the South Africa Communists' Party (SACP) who was martyred in his fight against apartheid in South Africa.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I will like to thank Sabstance for those very interesting and well argued positions in favor of Jacob Zuma. For me DK's mention of Zuma's questionable judgment sums up all there is to say about Mr Zuma. The fact that JZ has done some very great things for South Africa doesn't mean we should over look the not so great things he has done. Sabstance, are u saying that everyone who laid down their lives for the ANC is qualified to be president? If so, the next question is, were they doing this for the political reward or for genuine reasons?

    IF JZ truly had the interests of SA at heart, he will admit that he represents a polarizing force in South African politics, accept that he cannot be everything to South Africans and become the national statesman that he so much deserves to be. I mean does Zuma have to be president by all means?
    You can put up all the arguments that you want but the truth of the matter is that Zuma's election can best be described as a quid pro quo situation for his involvement in the apartheid era struggle. I wonder how many of his type the ANC has to appease before SA goes into self-destruct mode.

    ReplyDelete